1 in 3 Rural Americans Struggle to Afford Health Care

Medical expenses are more difficult to pay for than food and housing, a new poll finds.

By Gaby Galvin, Staff Writer?May 21, 2019
By Gaby Galvin, Staff Writer?May 21, 2019, at 12:02 a.m.
U.S. News & World Report

Struggle for Health Care in Rural Areas

A nurse takes the pulse of a patient at a free health clinic on July 22, 2017 in Wise, Virginia. Appalachia residents received free medical, dental and vision services at the Remote Area Medical (RAM), clinic held annually at the Wise County Fairgrounds in western Virginia. Wise County is one of the poorest in Virginia, and many of its residents have no dental insurance.

A nurse takes the pulse of a patient at a free health clinic in Wise, Virginia. About a quarter of rural adults have skipped health care at some point because they lacked either financial or physical access to care, a new survey found.John Moore/Getty Images

About 1 in 3 rural Americans say they've struggled to afford health care in recent years – even more so than the share who have had trouble paying for food or housing, a new survey indicates.

Rural communities – which tend to be older, poorer and sicker than urban areas – can face a complex set of challenges in accessing health care and other services. In all, about 4 in 10 rural adults have struggled to afford medical bills, housing or food in recent years, according to the new poll of about 1,400 rural adults was conducted by the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, NPR and the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.

About a quarter of rural adults have skipped health care at some point because they lacked either financial or physical access to care, the survey found. While rural adults without health insurance were more likely to forgo care than those who had health coverage, 24% of insured adults had not received the care they needed, the survey found.

"Even with major improvements in health insurance coverage over the last decade, it is concerning that 1 in 4 rural Americans are struggling to get the health care they need," Robert Blendon, a health policy professor and senior associate dean at Harvard and co-director of the survey, said in a statement.

The most common reasons people didn't receive health care were affordability, a health care provider being too far away or difficult to get to, not being able to get an appointment during certain hours and not being able to find a doctor who took their health insurance, the survey found.

Recent hospital closures in rural areas make health care access even more difficult, the report noted. Eight percent of rural adults said local hospitals had shuttered in recent years, with two-thirds saying the closures were problematic for their communities.

More than 60 rural hospitals closed across the U.S. between 2013 and 2017, driven in part by a falling number of people seeking inpatient care and reductions in Medicare payments, according to a 2018 report from the federal Government Accountability Office. A separate analysis published earlier this year found that about 1 in 5 rural hospitals were at risk of closure if their financial situations did not improve.

Access to care isn't the only health-related challenge rural Americans face. Housing problems, lack of internet access and overall financial insecurity affect "a smaller but considerable share" of families, the report says, with possible negative implications for health and community well-being.

About 1 in 5 rural adults said they worried about how their housing conditions might affect their family's health or safety, for example, with major issues including pests and bugs, drinking water safety, electrical issues and sewage system problems.

Rural America also has not been immune from the national housing shortage, and the lack of affordable housing in rural areas represents a "looming crisis," according to the Housing Assistance Council, a nonprofit focusing on rural housing.

In some rural areas, homelessness already is a top concern, the survey indicates. In the Pacific West -- including rural areas in Alaska, California, Hawaii, Oregon and Washington -- about half of adults said homelessness was a major problem in their communities, compared with 11% of adults in Appalachia and 19% in the Northeast.

"Isolation, loneliness, and homelessness are identified as problems among a smaller proportion of rural Americans but remain concerning due to their negative health effects and impacts on certain rural subpopulations," the report says.

Despite these challenges, rural Americans generally reported high levels of social and civic engagement, were satisfied with their quality of life and viewed their communities as safe, the survey found.

The findings help provide "a more complete understanding of the challenges to being healthy and the strengths of rural places in fostering good health," Richard Besser, president and CEO of the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, said in a statement.

Yet even with their advantages, "it's sobering to see that rural families struggle to pay for housing or food, go without needed medical care and lack financial security and essentials like high-speed internet access," Besser said.

Gaby Galvin, Staff Writer

Gaby Galvin is a staff writer at U.S. News & World Report. You can follow her on Twitter and ...? Read more

Recommended Articles

Healthiest Communities

After Birth, Opioids' Toll Continues

Healthiest Communities

America's Health Equity Problem

Pennsylvania News

Pennsylvania Holds up Philadelphia Hospital's Closing Plan

Healthiest Communities

Food Banks Aim to Address Diaper Needs


1 Child Dies, 3 Sickened by E. Coli Linked to San Diego Fair

Authorities say E. coli bacteria encountered at the San Diego County Fair has killed one child and sickened three others.

Associated PressJune 29, 2019

After Birth, Opioids' Toll Continues

A new study offers some of the most concrete evidence yet of how a mother’s drug use while pregnant can affect her child’s health outcomes.

Gaby GalvinJune 28, 2019

America's Health Equity Problem

A new study shows 'a worrisome lack of progress on health equity' in the country over 25 years.

Katelyn Newman June 28, 2019

Health Panel: Millions of US Kids Should Get Hepatitis Shot

Scientific panel recommends millions of US kids get vaccinated against hepatitis A.

Associated PressJune 27, 2019

Food Banks Aim to Address Diaper Needs

Diapers aren’t covered under subsidized programs for food or medical needs, but legislators in the Golden State are trying to address the issue.

Lauren KatimsJune 27, 2019

Vaccine No Match Against Flu Bug That Popped Up Near End

U.S health officials say the flu vaccine disappointed once again.

Associated PressJune 27, 2019

US Vaccine Panel Downgrades Pneumonia Shot Recommendation

A federal scientific panel on Wednesday downgraded its recommendation that retirement-age Americans get a top-selling vaccination against a bacteria that can cause pneumonia, meningitis and other illnesses.

Associated PressJune 26, 2019

Vaccine Panel Gives Nod to HPV Shots for Men up to Age 26

A U.S. government advisory panel has decided that a vaccine against cervical and other cancers should be recommended for both men and women up to age 26.

Associated PressJune 26, 2019

San Francisco Bans E-Cigarette Sales

The new ban is the most sweeping restriction yet in a city that has moved aggressively to curb e-cigarette use.

Gaby GalvinJune 26, 2019

NM Officials Warn of Hantavirus

New Mexico health officials are urging caution while cleaning following the death of a 42-year-old woman in the state.

Katelyn Newman June 26, 2019

Healthiest Communities

in collaboration with
Healthiest Communities is an interactive destination for consumers and policymakers, developed by U.S. News & World Report in collaboration with the Aetna Foundation, an independent charitable and philanthropic affiliate of CVS Health. Backed by in-depth research and accompanied by news and analysis, the site features comprehensive rankings drawn from an examination of nearly 3,000 counties and county equivalents on 81 metrics across 10 categories, informing residents, health care leaders and officials about local policies and practices that drive better health outcomes for all. Data were gathered and analyzed by the University of Missouri Center for Applied Research and Engagement Systems (CARES).